Like Bruce Springsteen’s Seeger Sessions band, the ensemble is founded on the principle that folk music can also be dance music. Where the former group’s cavalcade of trombones and fiddles overflowed with ecstasy, Weir’s group is swishier and more straightlaced, occasionally coming off like a soul revue. In “The Other One,” they circle around the rhythm, the horns and piano coaxing Weir into the vocals like the JBs playing their boss onto the stage. They turn “Eyes of the World” into a ballroom shuffle that’s dewy with nostalgia, Chimenti throwing complicated chords that resound like questions and playing his way in and out of key like Thelonious Monk. The band sidesteps into “What’s Going On” in a starry-eyed flow state, with Weir altering Marvin Gaye’s lyrics to decry “culture wars”—a dodgy move for any white artist covering a Black singer—and equivocating the original’s source of power. “Let’s hope that love will conquer hate,” he sings, his uncertainty regarding its efficacy at least in keeping with the doubt-riddled ethos of the Dead’s songbook.
The Dead, after all, were not a reverential band. “Ripple” feints in the direction of psalmody, but it refuses to resolve itself, and makes a point of insisting that the listener has the imperative and responsibility to find their own way in the world. On Live in Colorado, the crowd is kept high in the mix as the band rounds into the song’s last verse, their collective rendition of the wordless coda making the entire thing feel like last call at a honky tonk. Weir takes “Brokedown Palace” to its vocal limits, fluttering the high notes like he’s waving goodbye along with the thousands of people singing the “fare thee well” chorus. Both songs are standout tracks from 1970’s American Beauty, and high points in the Dead catalog at large, but like any hymn, they achieve brilliance when they’re sung loudly and in earnest by a whole lot of people.
Across the Dead’s songbook, ambiguity and imperfection are spiritual principles to which one must submit oneself. “His job is to shed light, and not to master,” Weir sings of the storyteller in “Terrapin Station,” the song suite presented here in its entirety. The original band never performed “Terrapin Station” all the way through, and on Live in Colorado, the track’s 21 minutes are stitched together from a pair of performances, with Wolf Bros. having played the first half one night and the second half the next.
It’s one of the more beguiling songs Garcia and lyricist Robert Hunter ever wrote: The opening guitar line, one of Garcia’s most delicate, seems to weave itself into being, and Hunter’s lyric uses a tale of thwarted love to suggest that heaven isn’t a place we set out to find so much as the product of the quest itself. Weir makes his way through the song with care, his oaken tone bringing a new level of gravitas to a song that’s already been invested with plenty of it. He knows how to rest the melody, dropping into a speaking voice for half a line, sharpening the story and drawing the listener in closer. Even if the technique is the byproduct of age—and his stunning performance on a dark and drifting “Days Between” suggests that Weir has greater control over his voice now than he ever has—the way his vocal ebbs and flows, gathering strength and spending it, reflects the song’s imperative to push onward despite knowing one’s limitations. Fifty-five years into a career that continues to take surprising and emotionally affecting shape, it suggests that Weir’s greatest audience is himself.
